I must admit that like others, I really enjoy the photo coverage done by Jean Cazes. He walks all over the neighborhood of Limoilou, camera in hand, and uses photography to tell us about his changing neighborhood, and everyday things that escape our attention. However, it is not Jean who will be the subject of this article, but rather, his recent photographic experience with the eco-neighborhood of Estimauville’s early stages of development, which made me reflect on the issue.
My first thought: it is sad to see the eco-neighborhood taking shape without any “eco-neighborhood” developing along with it! If we really think about it, these developments tell us a lot about the true label we need to attach to this neighborhood, which is not ready to see the light of day, for that matter. Will it be an eco-neighborhood or just simply a “nice, new neighborhood,” full of pretty buildings?
Let’s return to the basic principles of eco-neighborhoods in regards to transportation. Among these, Quebec City’s site mentions “Development of a network of streets whose design favors pedestrians; Networking of foot and bike paths in order to promote active forms of transportation.”
After noting Estimauville’s initial developments, we could ask ourselves how these sidewalks and walkways favor pedestrians. They are high-quality, but are otherwise completely similar to the pedestrian walkways and sidewalks found throughout the city. Yet, there is an array of guides and development tools that enable projects to put pedestrians first. One example comes from NACTO (National Association of City Transportation Officials), a non-profit organization that recently published a guide for developing intersections and streets that privilege pedestrians. Here, we find avant-garde models including raised pedestrian walkways, raised sidewalk sections that mitigate automobile risks while allowing greater visibility for pedestrians, and shared streets for both automobiles and bicycles – a concept that is still under-utilized in Quebec.
To end, there is some good news for Estimauville as well as for Pointe-aux-Lièvres, another eco-district. It is not too late to change course, as the majority of these neighborhoods remain unfinished.
Outside of official definitions and guidelines, which characteristics best define eco-neighborhoods? Does the term risk becoming meaningless?
Credits: Images and data linked to sources.
Original article, originally published in French, here.