April 25 2013

Close But No Cigar: A Review of James S. Russell’s The Agile City

The Agile City

In recent years we have begun to feel the effects of climate change the world over. In America, hurricanes like Superstorm Sandy and Katrina brought urban areas to their knees, killing people, destroying communities, and causing untold billions in damage. In this context, urban analyst and historian James S. Russell’s book The Agile City calls for a fundamental re-thinking of many of the systems shaping urban areas today. In an uncertain world fraught with climate risks both known and not yet realized, Russell re-prioritizes agility, or the ability of a city to adapt with changing circumstances, as the main criterion for future success.

Russell’s comprehensive, systems-based approach shows much promise in the early going, as he thoroughly analyzes some of the mis-incentives shaping real estate development, affordable housing, water management, and transportation. Where other theorists have gushed over costly advanced building techniques, electric cars, or other “silver bullet” solutions, Russell’s call for a re-thinking and re-invention of entire systems shows remarkable sobriety. No, Russell reminds us, the industrial designers alone will not bail us out of this one. If we are to truly re-create the civic space in which physical places are made, we will need committed business leaders, policy makers, engineers, architects and planners to make hard choices. It is not enough for an architect to produce some inspiring renderings – they too must grapple with a financial structure that incentivizes short-term real estate investing, wasting space and resources in the process.

Russell’s description of urban issues is one of the most comprehensive available, for which he is to be commended. How we actually begin the difficult task of creating agile cities however is less clear. While Russell’s cogency in summarizing what is wrong is certainly praiseworthy, his relative incoherence in proposing a way forward is not wholly his fault, for if anyone really knew the answers, there would be no book to write. So, The Agile City has the unfortunate task of making revolutionary change seem universally feasible and virtually pain-free. Russell is left only with the enfeebled options of “encouraging dialogue” and identifying a smattering of sometimes questionable case studies (Hamburg’s HafenCity among them). That’s not to say that his “sketches” of an agile urban future are entirely without value, but when compared to the colossal challenge ahead they leave readers craving more.

HafenCity

Hamburg's HafenCity

A true instruction manual to an “agile” future this book is not, but for an uninitiated audience there are few texts comparable to The Agile City in terms of its comprehensive approach and efficient language. The architects, urban planners, and environmentalists hoping for bold leadership from this text will have to keep searching, as James S. Russell sadly will not lead the coming revolution.

What tactics should planners use to affect systemic change?

The Agile City is available from Island Press in either paperback, hardback, or e-book version for between $16.99 and $35.00. To order your copy, visit the publisher’s website. The Grid is giving away four free copies of The Agile City. Enter, below, before May 2, 2013. Best of luck!

Win your free copy of James S. Russell’s “The Agile City:” Rafflecopter giveaway.

Credit: Images and data linked to sources.

Andrew Kinaci

After graduating from Princeton University with an A.B. in Architecture and a Certificate in Urban Studies, Andrew Kinaci set out to the Midwest to break out of the insular world of academia, and into the direct service of non-profit work. After a year working on Chicago’s West Side with a social enterprise specializing in re-entry employment training for ex-felons, Andrew now works for an organization conducting energy audits of multi-family affordable housing buildings. He will be blogging about the many ways Chicago is seeking a more sustainable and equitable urban future.

This entry was posted on Thursday, April 25th, 2013 at 1:02 am and is filed under Architecture, Community/Economic Development, Energy, Environment, Government/Politics, History/Preservation, Housing, Infrastructure, Land Use, Landscape Architecture, Transportation, Urban Development/Real Estate, Urban Planning and Design. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Share

2 Responses to “Close But No Cigar: A Review of James S. Russell’s The Agile City”

  1. Alie Cote Says:

    I think this article highlights a so called ‘emerging trend’ (that has always been present) in planning and design. That cities are a composite of organic systems working together, not individual sites and elements. Furthermore, ‘designed’ cities often neglect the importance of the non-physical organic systems such as political ecomomies and social networks. I would be interested to learn more about how Russell approaches the non-physical aspects of city infrastructure, as these intangibles vary by place and are constantly changing, therefore how does one perscribe a plausible solution?

  2. Media Report 5.3 Says:

    [...] review and book giveaway of The Agile City were featured on Global Site Plans [...]

Leave a Reply


− three = 4

 

Follow US

Categories